Warning: Spoilers Ahead So, I thought this book was good. It had amazing character development, fascinating backstories, and I loved how the pictures fit so well in the book. I loved Emma's character, and how realistically she felt about Jacob, and how the settings in this book were so detailed and different than the other. I liked how Jacob actually thought about his family instead of having them completely thrown out the story. I'm especially intrigued by Millard, and his love for knowledge (particularly about Peculiars) and I thought the the entire history of Peculiars and how the Wights were looking for Peculairs' souls was very original. The humor in this book is perfect, and I love the interactions between all of them. I love how Bronwyn is sort of like a mother/big sister towards Claire and Olive. The cliffhanger at the end was perfect, and I don't think I would a change a thing about this book. AWESOME BOOK 10/10

So, when I first read this book, I thought it was just going to be something that wasn't too great. But as I read on, I realized how unique the characters were, and how different it was then some other stories. Mind you, I haven't read this book in a while, but when Salim disappeared, I was vying to know. It's amazing book, I definitely recommend reading this, I loved this book.

SPOILERS ;) Sweetie (If anyone understands that Doctor Who reference, you're awesome) Alright, I read this book after it got famous, so the hype for it was fairly high, with everyone raving about how it made them cry, how it's "HOW IT IS THE BEST BOOK EVAARrRR", but when I finished it, I was kind of just like, "Oh well, let's get on to the next book." I was pretty excited about reading it, but right from the start it seemed kind of... well, boring. It seemed pretty obvious that someone was going to die, and it kind of emphasized the fact that it was either going to be Hazel or Augustus. It was predictable in my opinion, and I didn't cry and I wasn't sad. It was definitely interesting, but it wasn't all that great. Maybe this book just isn't for me, but it was boring. It carried on and on and on, and I knew from the start that he was going to die. Whatever, I give this book 2.5 stars. :3